YspeopleExplore tab

Ysbuys

Ysepicure

Keep politics out of policing and our courts


About JK

A frustrated academic, I want to start a social movement that will bring people together to create a better world. The world is far from ideal and who is going to change it if we don’t?

Happiness is a birth right and at the very least, a worthy ambition for us all. We have a responsibility to work together to help all people experience happiness. Please join with me


Our federal politicians have been dancing on dangerous, sacrosanct ground when it comes to policing and our judiciary -- and it must stop!

Just a few weeks ago, Sydney man Chan Han Choi was arrested by the federal police in Australia for selling classified information. He was apparently charged with offences relating to selling information that might facilitate the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

Separation of powers is about keeping the bastards honest.

Separation of powers is about keeping the bastards honest. Now we're on dangerous ground. Picture: Shutterstock

Media reports suggested this was very good work by the Australian Federal Police, a point well made by the Prime Minister.

In addition to praising the AFP on their good work, the Prime Minister also took credit for their resourcing and overall performance. In my view, this is a dangerous step too far -- and one of many examples in recent years where senior politicians, who should know better, have tried to leverage police forces or the courts for their political gain.

The Prime Minister also suggested last year, during question time in the House of Representatives, that he had advice that the High Court would subsequently rule Barnaby Joyce was not a duel citizen of Australia and New Zealand. It, of course, did not ‘so rule’. But again, the Prime Minister got involved with the legal system.

For many, this is almost certainly a small thing, and some don't see it as an issue at all. Some even believe his behaviour entirely justified, if not appropriate. I don't. I view it as a big issue and entirely inappropriate of the Prime Minister.

Malcolm Turnbull is not the sole offender, either. Bill Shorten and the ALP have also made comments about the police and courts. And in the US, President Donald Trump has made any number of divisive, critical and downright disgraceful comments about the judiciary, in particular. Trump is the worst of all.

While it is not well understood by most in the community, or indeed many politicians, I am a big fan of the separation of powers -- and in doing everything possible, and I mean everything, to protect this fundamental tenant of the Westminster system of government.

The separation of powers -- which  is not the same in the United States, because it does not have a Westminster system of government -- involves power in government existing in three independent silos: the legislature, the executive and the judiciary. Under this system, these three silos are not only independent, but they should not interfere with or influence each other. Rather, they should monitor each other and keep each other honest.

It is a protection against corruption.

The legislature in Australia’s case comprises the House of Representatives and the Senate. The executive in Australia comprises the Prime Minister and the Cabinet, with the input of the Governor-General as required. The judiciary comprises all arms of the police and all courts in the legal system. That these three silos are watching over each other to keep each other honest is central to the success of our democracy.

In my view, this tenant of the Westminster system is so important it should be sacrosanct. There should be absolutely no grey areas. This tenant of the system is so important that all political parties and politicians should be expected by us, the community, to never cross any lines. While politicians can praise the police for their good work, and the judiciary for their hard work, it should never go any further than this.

Politicians should never lecture the police or courts, as several have done (including Health Minister Greg Hunt last year). They should never criticise judgments, offer gratuitous advice, take credit for their success, or predict how they will act or rule.

Not only is it essential that governments and oppositions not influence the police or judiciary, it is equally important that they are not seen to try. It is critically important that politicians never do anything to diminish absolute confidence in the police or judiciary, except under extreme circumstances of corruption or malpractice.

I also support development of a federal crime and corruption commission, to which all concerns about the behaviour of people within any of these three silos can be referred.

To work well, there also needs to be a genuine bipartisan, common multi-party agreement on these issues.

What say you?

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet


Related stories

Embrace training to stay relevant in an ever-changing workplace.

How to stay relevant at work

 

Companies are moving toward automation over human skills. Here's what you need to do to stay relevant at work.

Money Work
Expand
Almost 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
That desperation to ''know'' and be right can cause so much unnecessary conflict.

When 'knowing' is dangerous

 

Nothing starts more conflict than people ''knowing'' stuff.

Community Politics Philosophy
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Do you trust politicians? Picture: Shutterstock.

Why don’t we trust politicians?

Here are my top five reasons that politicians are not trusted -- and they all relate to behaviour.

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Who is going to make their country better for their children, if they don’t? Picture: Shutterstock.

The real refugee question

All three of the common arguments against refugees have ignorance at their root. But there is one question yet to be addressed.

Social Issues Politics Middle East Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Lines of people wait to collect natural spring water for drinking during the Cape Town drought.

Water: a crisis in the making

Cape Town is about to run out of water -- and 11 other major cities are facing the same plight. Horrifying, isn't it?

Travel Environment Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
PM Malcolm Turnbull attends another military show of strength.

Why the obsession with war?

Why we must rethink our view of the military -- and care more for our returned soldiers.

Community Politics Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Finding your mythical purpose.

Perhaps it's your 'fate' to read this post

Why it pays to create your own purpose ... and other philosophical musings.

Community Phhilosophy
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
We have a beautiful country but is our national anthem accurate? (Image: Shutterstock).

Australia's national anthem a disappointment

 

As far as national anthems go, Advance Australia Fair fails to mean much to me. Here's why.

Culture History Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Boofhead and Moralising.

F**k boofhead Barnaby and moralising Malcolm

The grubbiness of the Barnaby Joyce affair shows there is pain ahead for many, including the good voters of Australia.

Relationships Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)
Shop safely from the comfort of home by following these simple rules.

Shop safely online with these simple rules

 

Wondering what all the fuss is about with online shopping, but scared of being ripped off? Don't worry, we'll steer you right.

Money Technology
Expand
About 6 years ago
(Ys Comment)

Message board

Rachel, about 3 years ago:
I am Sav
Rachel, about 3 years ago:
Hello
Derek, almost 6 years ago:
I am great
George, almost 6 years ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, almost 6 years ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, almost 6 years ago:
Hello
Thomas, almost 6 years ago:
Great!
DJC, almost 6 years ago:
Groovy!
George, almost 6 years ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
They may be hideous, but geez, some toby jugs are valuable.

Is your toby jug worth a fortune?

Did you know that some of...

(Nostalgia) Almost 6 years ago
Paris Mitchell motivates students at Joseph Banks Secondary College.

Students motivated at Joseph Banks Secondary College

Students motivated at...

(Kindness) About 6 years ago
In Australia, we follow the Queen's english, but ugly Americanisms are sneaking in.

What are we doing to our language?

Read what peeves this...

(Entertainment & Culture) About 6 years ago
Overcome your self-doubt to reach your potential in 2018.

Reject damaging self-doubt in 2018

After all, who are you not...

(Health & Beauty) Over 6 years ago
You may be fit, but regular medical checkups are crucial Picture: Youtube.

Dean Mercer: A tragic reminder to get a checkup

The sudden death of Ironman...

(Health & Beauty) Over 6 years ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
Hizgg0vzzqvwc9xicknk
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.