Stranger

Who thinks Ian Narev is worth $12M a year?


Thumb angry biker showing middle finger with both hands 000078716059 small

About Subversive

There is something just not right about our world and it involves the self centred, self serving nature of people.


Is it really ethical for a CEO to accept $12 million a year while working hard to keep employee incomes as low as possible?

Who on earth thought the Commonwealth Bank of Australia's CEO was worth a ludicrous $12 million a year? CBA chair Catherine Livingston obviously did, along with the board.

Is Commonwealth bank boss Ian Narev's multimillion-dollar pay packet unethical.

Is Commonwealth bank boss Ian Narev's multimillion-dollar pay packet unethical. We'd love to hear your thoughts. Picture: YouTube

That said, after the latest scandal involving the CBA, Ian Narev has had his income for the current year cut to $10 million.

Read more Subversive Sam: Together, the over-50s can change the world

And at the bank's annual general meeting next week, the CBA's remuneration submission will be tabled and shareholders can have their say on whether Mr Narev is worth even the $10 million a year he will receive. 

My guess is that many smaller shareholders will not see real value in this salary, while representatives of larger shareholders, also receiving very high incomes, will support the current remuneration structure at the CBA. I also expect the latter to carry the day.

I don't think Ian Narev is worth $10 million a year. Certainly, he has delivered six years of profit growth, along with a steadily rising share price and very attractive dividends for shareholders.

What do you think? Do you agree with Subversive Sam? Please share your thoughts in the comments, or by signing in and posting your thoughts via your unique member dashboard. 

But at what cost?

There have been numerous scandals and there is growing evidence that the battle for short-term profit growth may damage the long-term future of the bank.

That said, I think the more important question here is not what Ian Narev is worth, but what  is ethically right to pay him. Put simply, is it ethically reasonable to pay any business executive $12 million a year, especially when that business is working over-time to minimise income growth of middle management and staff?

Is it ethically sound to pay Ian Narev even $10 million a year - when the bank has allegedly broken so many laws, and caused so many people pain through its superannuation and insurance divisions? Is It ethical to pay Ian Narev even half this amount, given the culture of ‘profit at any cost’ that he seems to have established at the CBA?

For too long now, big business has told us that high salaries and bonuses paid to the likes of Ian Narev are necessary to attract the best people. I have met a lot of these people and can say with absolute confidence that there are few that are special in any way.

In the case of Ian Narev, I would simply ask the board of the CBA, ‘is Ian Narev REALLY the best you can do?’ Is a man incapable of developing a culture that builds profits in the short term while sacrificing reputation in the long term, while burning innocent superannuants along the way, really the best you can do?

The problem here may lie with the board. They too are paid well for their questionable contribution. Chairman Catherine Livingston is paid nearly a million dollars and boards members are paid in excess of $300,000 per annum each. Some are past public company CEOs themselves. Therefore, they have a vested interest in perpetuating the myth that executives like Ian Narev are worth the money paid.

There is another perspective that also needs to be considered here.

How ethical is it to pay Ian Narev $10 million per annum, and the CEO of the CSIRO a few hundred thousand dollars a year? How ethical is it to pay a senior executive $10 million per annum and a school teacher less than $100,000? How ethical is it to pay a CEO $10 million and the Prime Minister $500,000?

The top end of town will tell us that this is not about ethics, but the market. The market drives the income of senior executives and the other people I have noted. Of course, they would say that. They have a very clear vested interest in saying that. They also have a vested interest in doing whatever they can to ensure that their workforces earn as little as possible.

I find it interesting that so many in our community are still fooled by the ‘market’ argument. I am surprised that our community has not become more irritated about the behaviour of these executives and the boards that appoint them.

Remember, these are the same executives and boards that tell the Federal Government that it is spending too much on pensions and unemployment benefits. This is the same group that tells the Fair Work Commission that business cannot afford to pay higher wages. This is the same team of greedy individuals that screws suppliers, no matter how much hardship it creates for the low-paid workers they employ.

If people want to suggest that I am indulging is class warfare, then so be it! 

They can call it whatever they want. At this point, words mean little. What matters most in my view is ethical behaviour.. I don't believe that the board of the CBA iscting ethically in offering Ian Narev $12 million in the first place, and Ian Narev is not acting ethically in accepting it while working cap his own employees' incomes.

Paying Ian Narev is unethical self-interest at its worst.

Suggesting he is worth the money he is paid is a well-orchestrated con!

  • YsPeople is a community for the wise. You can voice your opinion on anything here. Simply sign in to post your poems, reviews, opinions and life stories via your unique member dashboard.
  • | Your rating
    1 members rated this article


    Related stories

    The credit cards with the longest interest-free periods

    Comment icon 16

    There’s a lot more to interest-free days than you might think.

    Money
    Originally from moneymag.com.au
    Expand
    4 days ago
    (Money & Business)
    Keep your speech as simple as possible.

    The art of public speaking - Part 1

    Comment icon 16

    What you say is not as important as you'd think.

    Community Relationships Hobbies Business
    Expand
    6 days ago
    (Money & Business)
    The 1966 wavy baseline 20 cent coin is worth a small fortune.

    There's hidden treasure in your loose change

    Comment icon 16  

    It's time to start checking your change, folks! This 20 cent coin can be worth hundreds - or thousands in mint condition.

    Hobbies Money
    Expand
    6 days ago
    (Money & Business)

    Credit card shake-up: cards offering top rewards

    Comment icon 16

    While more card providers are expected to devalue their rewards programs, the good news for fans of rewards is that there are...

    Australia Money
    Originally from moneymag.com.au
    Expand
    6 days ago
    (Money & Business)
    ,.

    CEO Ian Narev to leave Commonwealth Bank

    Comment icon 16

    Commonwealth Bank CEO Ian Narev to retire before July 2018 as the bank deals with money-laundering scandal.

    Business Money
    Originally from abc.net.au
    Expand
    7 days ago
    (Money & Business)

    5 ways to boost your super without an extra cent

    Comment icon 16

    Here are five easy ways to make sure you're not missing out on benefits.

    Superannation Money
    Originally from moneymag.com.au
    Expand
    7 days ago
    (Money & Business)
    Courting controversy, the Commonwealth Bank.

    The CBA culture wars continue

    Comment icon 16

    Once again, the Commonwealth Bank is in the firing line.

    Social Issues Business Money
    Expand
    10 days ago
    (Money & Business)

    Cool business card ideas that will get you noticed

    Comment icon 16

    One of the quickest and most effective ways to get your name out there when promoting your career is the business card.

    Business Art Design
    Originally from mymodernmet.com
    Expand
    11 days ago
    (Money & Business)

    9 car, home and travel insurance hacks

    Comment icon 16

    Save your hard-earned cash with these top tips

    Australia Property Money
    Originally from moneymag.com.au
    Expand
    12 days ago
    (Money & Business)

    Mark Zuckerberg's political ambitions

    Comment icon 16

    He’s probably going to seek higher office one day, and it looks like he’s already preparing for the job.

    Technology United States Politics
    Originally from vanityfair.com
    Expand
    12 days ago
    (Money & Business)
    Weekly Poll
    Quote of the day
    Mr8rbbhoqyf3fm24eobb
    Joke of the day
    T3sdrfenqyfwhpexkrcb
    Beat this!
    Gxruu90mex9wl9jnlf4f
    YsPeople proudly supports
    Sqytulzsuesrikzdgat0
    Ysepicure logo new.tiny

    Stay up to date and get special offers first with our weekly YsPeople newsletter.

    Join