YspeopleExplore tab

Ysbuys

Ysepicure

Debate is so much bigger than same-sex marriage


About Philosophically

I think, therefore I am.


Here's four extra - and incredibly powerful - reasons to vote in favour of marriage equality.

The current debate about same-sex marriage is about a great deal more than two people of the same gender being able to have their union recognised by law in Australia.

Four extra reasons to vote for marriage equality.

Four extra reasons to vote for marriage equality. Picture: Shutterstock

While I am not gay and see no merit in marriage, I am an emphatic supporter of allowing same-sex marriages to be recognised in law.

There are two principle reasons for my support. They are:

  • The fact that marriage is an entirely man-made concept that should mean whatever we want it to mean.
  • The issues at stake are far greater than two people of the same gender having their marriage recognised in law.
  • On the first point, the High Court of Australia once ruled that the Constitution allowed for marriage to be between any two individuals, without reference to the gender of either. It was the Howard government that introduced laws that defined marriage as involving a man and a woman. There is absolutely no reason for it to stay that way.

    Behind this debate about the legal recognition of gay marriage are four principles that make the debate about much more than two people being able to have their union recognised in law, as important as that may be.

    The first relates to what should be the inalienable right of every human being to do whatever they like if it does not affect anyone else.

    Setting aside the misleading suggestions in some advertising - which have conflated a range of unrelated factors with gay marriages being recognised in law - two people marrying, regardless of their gender, have no direct affect on anyone other than the two concerned. What right do we have to interfere in the relationship of two other people? Their actions can do NOTHING to others, beyond making some of them happy.

    The second of these principles relates to the view held by some that gay marriage is against the word of God. Even if this is true, like so many things that are supposedly against the word of God, this is surely a matter between the individuals concerned and God.

    Why would man need to get involved in the matter? If God objects to a person’s behaviour, then it is up to God to take it up with them and penalise them if need be. This is not a matter for me, or you.

    The third principle relates to the ethics of denying another human being happiness. I cannot image how marriage would make anyone happy, but I know that marriage makes some people very happy. Further, I just cannot see that I have any right to deny someone that happiness just because something, perhaps marriage, makes them happy.

    I am strongly of the view that it is immoral to restrict the behaviour of another just because I don’t like that behaviour, particularly where there is no direct negative impact on me. I believe that in such circumstances, denying happiness is unacceptably selfish.

    Finally, there is the inherent stupidity in trying to prevent something that is inevitable.

    The dumbest thing I ever heard a prime minister say was: "I know Australia will become a republic, but it will not happen on my watch." 

    This was said by the same man who changed the law on marriage last time – proving that an Act of Parliament is all it takes to define marriage.

    Australia will become a republic one day and the mature approach is work with this proposition and make sure it happens in the best possible way. Simply delaying it is juvenile.

    The same applies to same-sex marriage. The ALP will be re-elected one day (possibly sooner rather than later) and when they are, they will recognise gay marriage – and may do it in a way not ideal for religious organisations.

    Is it therefore not smarter for those concerned about gay marriage to become part of the solution, and make sure it occurs with what they see as appropriate exclusions for religious bodies and others.

    These issues are all bigger than same-sex marriage, but they in themselves suggest that same-sex marriage is a right and should be recognised in law. They, of course, will not be accepted by the homophobic.

    Banner 1
    | Your rating
    No ratings yet


    Related stories

    Women cheat on men who don't do house chores: study

    Women are more likely to cheat on men who fail to pull their weight when it comes to household chores, according to a major...

    Work Relationships
    Originally from telegraph.co.uk
    Expand
    Almost 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Marriage is a con, serving no purpose at all.

    Marriage is a symptom of ugliness

    Relationships and love have astonishing value. But marriage? Pffffft, what a con!

    Relationships Community Social Issues
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    By following a few commonsense rules, online dating isn't so scary after all.

    How to stay safe while dating online

     

    Have you found yourself single again in midlife? Thinking about online dating? Read this first.

    Relationships Technology Health
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Saying thankyou will brighten two people's day.

    The power of saying thankyou

    There is incredible power in saying thankyou and expecting nothing in return.

    Relationships Community Health
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Grandkids say the funniest things.

    The things your grandchildren say

    Children say the darndest things, don't they? Share your funny anecdotes.

    Relationships Community Humour
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Children need to know it's OK to bite, kick and scream if grabbed by a stranger.

    Nine life-saving lessons to teach your grandkids

    Here's how to equip your grandchildren with the tools to keep them safe from predators.

    Family Relationships Community Social Issues
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    We were like chalk and cheese.

    An overdue apology to my long-dead brother

    The pain following your death on that remote country road runs deep. Here's why I want to sorry.

    Family Relationships Loss
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    A class divided passport of the 80s.

    My passport is a snapshot of an uglier time

     

    You only have to look at my passport from the 1980s -- which lists me as black and bans me from travelling to South Africa --...

    Social Issues India Politics Australia
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Empty nesters, how did you celebrate winning your freedom back? Picture: Shutterstock.

    Empty nesters, let's hear your stories

    Alright all of you empty nesters, how did you celebrate your new-found freedom? Let's get a conversation started.

    Property Relationships Community
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)
    Baby Joyce.

    Marriage meltdown not Barnaby’s only failure

    Our Deputy PM's moral protestations about our interest in his love life go directly to the character of the man.

    Relationships Social Issues Politics Australia
    Expand
    About 6 years ago
    (Love & Relationships)

    Message board

    Rachel, about 3 years ago:
    I am Sav
    Rachel, about 3 years ago:
    Hello
    Derek, almost 6 years ago:
    I am great
    George, almost 6 years ago:
    What's up Thomas?
    George, almost 6 years ago:
    Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
    Thomas, almost 6 years ago:
    Hello
    Thomas, almost 6 years ago:
    Great!
    DJC, almost 6 years ago:
    Groovy!
    George, almost 6 years ago:
    Message board active from June 2018

    Have your say!

    Your Great Australians

    Trending stories
    They may be hideous, but geez, some toby jugs are valuable.

    Is your toby jug worth a fortune?

    Did you know that some of...

    (Nostalgia) Almost 6 years ago
    Dogs have much to teach us about living in the moment.

    The dog who made my life better

    The greatest gift of all...

    (Love & Relationships) Over 6 years ago
    I view these as the lost years of my life.

    The school of hard knocks - Part 2

    In his insightful, ongoing...

    (Love & Relationships) Over 6 years ago
    The historic Parkerville Tavern is starting to reveal its secrets.

    Parkerville Tavern's sordid history revealed

    Owners of the Parkerville...

    (Pastimes) Over 6 years ago
    When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

    20 mature bloggers worth following

    Looking for Australian...

    (Entertainment & Culture) About 7 years ago
    Weekly Poll
    Photographic memories
    Hizgg0vzzqvwc9xicknk
    It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.